FREE SHIPPING… ALWAYS!

RMS Beauty: Cashmere Matte Eyelights + Skin2Skin Everything Eye Polish Brush

by Cristina Montemayor

As a beauty editor and makeup artist I go through a lot of makeup, yet I can honestly say that I have never once hit pan on every shade in an eyeshadow palette. Eyeshadow palettes offer a variety of shades meant to mix and match, but who actually uses every shade in a palette? Most people, myself included, use a couple of shades until there’s nothing left and then stuff the rest of the unused palette in the back of a drawer never to be used again.

This feels like a safe space to admit that I have repurchased an eyeshadow palette because I hit pan on my favorite shades knowing full well that I will rarely, if ever, use most of the other shades in the palette. I know, I know, it’s so wasteful. If this were the mid to late 2000s, I would simply purchase eyeshadow singles in my go-to shades, but in 2025 single shadows are all but extinct. (R.I.P. Makeup Geek! Forever in our hearts.)

At least, that’s what I thought. But it turns out that single eyeshadows just went through their own evolution process, and now they’re better than ever. RMS Beauty’s Cashmere Matte Eyelights have taken the place of my long-standing go-to eyeshadow palette in my daily makeup bag. There are 8 shades, and my two favorites are Tundra Taupe and Dusty Trail.  Tundra Taupe is a light desert sand color, which is what I typically reach for to blend all over the lid. It’s a great base shade and also acts as a primer.  Dusty Trail is tawny camel brown, making it perfect for blending into the outer corner for added depth.

A cream eyeshadow might be intimidating at first glance, but dare I say, these matte cream shadows are even easier to blend than your typical powder eyeshadow. This latest launch is an extension of the Eyelights Cream Shadow range, which initially launched a few years ago with a number of shades in a metallic finish. I love a little sparkle on special occasions, but it’s not something I reach for on a daily basis so I was really excited to see the mattes.

I have some slight discoloration around my eyes, which I like to camouflage with a very neutral matte eyeshadow. Discoloration around the eyes tends to happen with age, and now that I’m firmly in my 30s, color correcting around the eyes has become part of my daily makeup routine. I loved the original RMS Eyelights formula for a more dramatic eye look, and this latest finish feels like it was made for me.  Matte, but not drying. RMS Beauty makes products with mature skin in mind, so think soft instead of powdery. The Cashmere Matte Eyelights have a matte pearl finish, which adds dimension without any in-your-face sparkles.

Another fun age-related face thing? Oily eyelids. I always wanted eyes that shine, but not like that. If the oil on my lids hasn’t completely devoured my eyeshadow by noon, it tends to congeal in the folds and wrinkles of my eye. These Cashmere Matte Eyelights last even longer on the lid than traditional powder eyeshadow and they don’t crease. Rosie Marie Swift, the legendary makeup artist turned female founder, promises eight hour all-day wear, which I thought would be more like four on me, thanks to my overactive oil glands. I was damn near shocked when I ended a long work day full of running around town, and the cream eyeshadow looked just as it did when I had left the house earlier in the morning.   

If you’re a fan of rms Beauty, you know that Rose Marie is a fan of using her fingers to apply makeup. The skin-to-skin application warms up the product, which helps with blendability and makes for a more natural application. Matte eyeshadows that are too pigmented tend to be difficult to blend, but leave it to Rose Marie to crack the code of matte shadows that don’t skip or leave harsh lines even when applied using just your fingers.  She’s a master and a legend.

If you’re not feeling brave enough to fingerpaint your eyeshadow, though, reach for the RMS Beauty Skin2Skin Everything Eye Polish Brush. Made with 100% vegan imitation goat hair, it’s soft to the touch and crafted in a rounded dome shape to perfectly blend out both cream and powder eyeshadow. You literally cannot go wrong. 

Makeup artist-led brands tend to lean on the artistry and techniques that makeup artists inherently know and understand. Makeup artists love pigmented products because they know what to do with them, but to the average person, blending these products out can be a nightmare. rms takes a different approach by taking makeup artist techniques and developing formulas that make those methods more accessible to the masses. This latest extension of the Eyelight family provides rich, multi-dimensional color with a subtle brilliance that blends effortlessly for a wash of color that’s suitable for daytime and buildable for dramatic effects at night.

While part of me still yearns for the days of single eyeshadows, Swift’s take on matte cream eyeshadows proves that eyeshadow evolution is real. As a 30-something-year-old woman with some slight discoloration and oily lids, I’m so here for this latest eyeshadow iteration from the one and only RMS Beauty. You’ve outdone yourself again, Rose Marie.

213Deli editors are beauty experts with eons of years of experience under our belts. We’ve tried it all and keep on trying everything new that comes out in an effort to save you the headache of wasting your time and money on things that aren’t worth it. We only write about and recommend products we truly love and are pretty sure you’ll also love. All products are chosen independently by our editorial team. If you buy something we link to, 213Deli may earn a commission.